Say what you will, but injuries to Posada, Matsui, Chamberlain and Wang, they finished what...8 games behind the Red Sox?
The teams are much closer than you think, SOTK. I wouldn't be surprised if the Yankees, Tampa or Boston finished 3rd. Flip a three-headed coin, if you will.
The truth is, from the Yankees standpoint, the one solid pitcher they had was Moose. Let's say the Yankees get CC. From a standpoint of production, Moose and the top-tier free agent pitcher they sign wash each other out. Any other pitcher they bring in replaces the immortals of Giese, Rasner, and Ponson.
Fool yourself if you want.