Well, the question becomes, what do you pay him to stay? I think the fans choice is to keep Papi. But Theo has been said to want flexibility, and when your DH is a guy who cannot do anything but, it kinda saps your flexibility. That being said, if you give a guy a full day and your DH hits to a .900OPS, then you should count your lucky stars. I think the sox will do with Papi what they did with all their aging stars. Offer them something they think is fair. If someone outbids them, then they wont chase him. I think there is a very real possibility that one of the teams in the AL will offer him 3 yrs. And while the sox might offer the most AAV, I doubt they go past 2. If papi wants to stay, then he takes the less years. If Papi doesnt, then he goes