Gullett wasnt just good. He was headed for greatness before he was cut down by injury. Gary Nolan was also a big top of the rotation arm on that Reds staff when healthy. He was more injury cursed than Gullett. The trash heap that we rolled out to start the 2015 season cannot be compared to the Reds staff in 1975. While I am sure that those WAR numbers for the Reds rotation are correct, I am also sure that they were heavily influenced by the managerial style of Sparky (Captain Hook) Anderson. He did not try to get 100 pitches from his starters. If his starters gave up 2 or 3 runs in the first inning and there were 5 base runners, he'd go to the pen. He had a bunch of good arms in his bullpen and he went to them early and often. He had no patience to let his starters work out of trouble.