Max, I come here to discuss sports, share ideas and have a good time doing it. I am not here to make cases backed with evidence. The story about the guy on the radio wasn't intended as evidence of anything. It was just a funny call I heard and I thought it demonstrated how every manager takes heat from the fan base and the media.
I made a very good living making arguments backed by evidence for over 30 years. I have no interest in making my enjoyment of baseball into a debate contest with other fans about topics that don't interest me like comparing managers, because I am not getting paid to do so. I am certain that if someone wanted to employ me to do so, I would leave you and your arguments in tatters and you would be looking for a safe space to go sob. LOL!!
I think you might be buying underwear that is 2 sizes too small, because you are just so cranky and combative. I have noooo interest in comparing these 2 dugout buffoons, never mind making a case backed with evidence. I am not trying to convince anyone else of my opinions. In this case, I think both managers are dopes, and frankly, I don't care if you think Farrell or Girardi would have been NASA scientists had it not been for choosing a baseball career. Do yo argue with yourself in front of your mirror? You are arguing with yourself on this topic.