He isn't as good as the other 3 OFers, but imo JD is a good OFer. He was a gold glove finalist a few years back. People can scoff if they like about the award, but while the award may not go to the most deserving player at time, the award winners and finalists are usually good fielders. JD doesn't need to be replaced defensively. We could have used his bat after he was removed, and Mookie could have PH for Vasquez.