I gave him a B+ for the bullpen moves, but they were overshadowed by a huge bungle with the arbitration offer to Ortiz and not filling the team's primary need -- a reliable starting pitcher. Also, he gets a downgrade for salary dumping Scutaro. It doesn't matter if Iglesias makes the team, which it is sounding like he will not, because Scutaro would have been a better utility guy than Punto. Getting a closer was not that hard. There were plenty available, and the one he got has a history of elbow problems.
If the Sox hadn't crumbled so badly last year, I would have grade him a C, but in the wake of that collapse, I felt there was a need to taker bolder action. They need to rebound from last season. My D was not disingenuous at all. I am surprised that no one gave him an F based solely on the fact that he didn't address the team's primary need. The so-called negative contingent showed fairness and restraint. The grade that is disingenuous are the A's. He missed an A solely on the Ortiz bungle. The people who voted an A know they have nothing to back it up, so they didn't even bother to try.