I was hoping for some analysis.
In 2005, the top 4 guys averaged around 200 innings and almost 15 wins, the depth option returning from ankle surgery was Schilling, who was still the ace when he got healthy
In 2006, they had 3 pitchers in the rotation that won 200 more games in their careers --Wells, Wakefield and Schilling. Clement was coming off a year with 13 wins and he was on the All Star team. Wells was coming off a 15 win season. There was no reason to believe he would fall of a cliff, or Clement would blow out his arm. s*** happens. You are judging 2006 with 20-20 hindsight. If judged at the moment when Spring Training ended, I don't know if I would come to the same conclusion. Also the the depth option of Lester was better than what we have in 2012.