I think we are over thinking this issue. We have 6 players that are all stars and then there is a big drop off for the bottom 3. Who hits where in the top 6 will in part depend on how they are doing. If each performs up to their expectations, the power hitters will be hitting 3 - 5 or 3-6. If Ells is still hitting HRs, he should be in the 3 hole, and we will have 4 legit power hitters. If CC hits like his Tampa Bay days, he should be in the 2 hole. If not, he'll hit 6th behind Ortiz. Lefty-Rights doesn't matter with our top 6. Their order doesn't much matter as long as they are all bunched together. It would not be smart to drop any of them into the bottom 3. Our bottom 3 is well below the class of the other 6.