I’m thinking Tito thought the game would go into extra innings and so he didn’t want to use Foulke until at least the 9th. Since Timlin wasn’t available, the call went to Riske, to face the bottom of the Jays order.
He had already gotten great relief work from the rookies, Seanez and Tavarez not available from yesterday’s game, Foulke and Paps being saved for the 9th and beyond, so who else, other than Riske, was left in the pen to be used?
Judging by Tito’s seldom use of Riske since his return from the DL, I’m thinking he has lost confidence in Riske. Obviously tonight’s outing didn’t help Riske’s cause.
In hindsight I probably would have brought Riske in yesterday’s game when it was 5-0, to give him some work then.