Sweet! I love speculation like this.
So here goes.
Schilling 17-11, 3.90 era. Leaves it all on the table in his final season.
Matsuzaka 15-8, 3.80 era. He will throw a lot of pitches and be out of games in the middle of the 6th inning. He'll get a lot of no decisions.
Beckett 16-12, 4.30 era. Until he changes his mindset or gets hurt, he is what he is.
Papelbon 8-4, 3.77 era as a starter
Wakefield 5-4 4.65 era as a starter
TBD - 8-10, 5.23 era
Wake starts the season as closer with Papelbon in the rotation.
Wake gets 26 save opportunities and goes 2-5 with 10 blown saves but does have 16 saves by the time Gagne can pitch. Gagne comes of the DL in June and pitches great for a month. He goes 1-1 with a 3 era and has 7 saves, then gets injured just after the trade deadline.
Papelbon is then thrust back into the closer role and collects 15 out of 19 saves (2007 total: 10-5, 3.52 era, 15 saves). Wake goes to the rotation to fill Paps spot and wins his games (5-4 4.65 era - 2007 total: 7-10, 4.47 era, 16 saves) .
Sox come in second to the Yanks and get the wildcard. They win the ALDS against TX but lose the ALCS to the Cleveland who wins the World Series over the Cubs.