Article: Baseball America Unveils May Top 100 Prospect List, Six Red Sox Prospects On It

[Nick John]

Baseball America unveiled their updated Top 100 prospects list for May, and the Boston Red Sox are well represented on it with six prospects making the cut. Adding to the impressive display of prospects was the fact the Red Sox had three prospects rank within the top 10. This is the second time since the end of the 2024 season where the Red Sox have had six prospects in the top 100.

Making the list were Roman Anthony, Kristian Campbell, Marcelo Mayer, Franklin Arias, Payton Tolle and Brandon Clarke. Tolle and Clarke are newcomers to the list after making their professional debuts this season.

Leading the way is Anthony, as the top prospect reclaimed the number one spot from Roki Sasaki after an outstanding April. Fans and other executives are wondering why Anthony hasn’t been called up to the majors yet after showing that he is more than ready, but for the time being, the outfielder continues to perform at a high level in Triple-A.

Currently third on the list is Campbell, as the second baseman continues a rookie campaign with Boston that saw him win the American League Rookie of the Month award for April. Campbell won’t be eligible for the list for much longer, as he’ll graduate from prospect status in the coming weeks. For now, he joins Anthony as one of the three Red Sox prospects in the top 10.

Joining the dynamic duo is the last member of the Big Three (and the longest tenured one) in Mayer. After dealing with injuries across multiple years, Mayer seems to be fully healthy, as he’s played excellently on both sides of the ball in Triple-A. Offensively, he leads Worcester in RBIs, and in the field he’s played phenomenal defense whether it’s at shortstop, second base or third base. Mayer ranked ninth in the latest BA list and could see himself move even higher should his play remain consistent.

The last member who was previously on the top 100 list is Franklin Arias, the sure-handed shortstop that was recently promoted to Greenville after a hot start to the season in Salem. The shortstop previously ranked 72nd and is now up to 68th on Baseball America's list. Originally signed for his glove, Arias has shown impressive improvement with his bat since signing and has quickly vaulted himself up several prospect ranking lists.

The first new comer for the Red Sox is Tolle, who ranked 94th on his first industry top 100 list. Tolle was drafted in the second round of the 2024 draft out of Texas Christian University and has made four starts for High-A Greenville. Tolle's most impressive skill may be his ability to rack up strikeouts. Through 14 2/3 innings, he’s earned 29 strikeouts thanks in part to his elite extension and velocity. Currently, his fastball tops out at 96 mph, but due to an extension of 7.4 feet on average, it allows his fastball to play above it’s velocity and appear faster. He also throws a sweeper, slider and changeup, and he's flashed advanced feel for each one as he hones his arsenal.

The final member of the Red Sox prospects on the Top 100 list is Brandon Clarke. The left-hander debuted in a big way, as he threw four perfect innings in his professional debut with Salem. The 22-year-old was promoted to Greenville after three starts that saw him strike out 17 batters in 9 2/3 innings. His impressive start continued in his Greenville debut, where he allowed only one unearned run in 4 2/3 innings while striking out seven. Clarke throws four pitches; a fastball that tops out at 100 mph, a slider, sweeper and changeup, which all lead to many swings and misses by opposing batters.

The Red Sox farm system has continued to show it’s elite ability to develop players, even after trading away Kyle Teel and Braden Montgomery and dealing with injuries to top pitching prospect Luis Perales. Even with a number of prospect graduations on the horizon, fans should be pleased at the health of the organization's player development pipeline.

View full article

[Hugh2]

Sox had 6 in the top 100, would be 8 if the Crochet deal never happened (Teel/Montgomery).  Perales was listed as someone who "just missed" 

[Larry Cook]

Arias is starting to get hot in Greenville. I really like his swing and eye at the plate. Still has a bit of rafeala in his swing though. 
the surprise of the year so far for me is how much better Anderson is swinging the bat. 
top of the lineup for Greenville has a lot of potential and should be fun to watch this summer. 

[moonslav59]

18 minutes ago, Larry Cook said:

Arias is starting to get hot in Greenville. I really like his swing and eye at the plate. Still has a bit of rafeala in his swing though. 
the surprise of the year so far for me is how much better Anderson is swinging the bat. 
top of the lineup for Greenville has a lot of potential and should be fun to watch this summer. 

Like Ceddanne, this guy is a tremendous defensive player, so maybe his bat need not be all that good to still be a big plus in the bigs, someday.

[Larry Cook]

Mayer, sogard, Grissom Worcester 

Romero, Liendo, erhard - Portland 

arias,  alcanterra, zanetello - Greenville

Things are clogging up on the development  front for middle infielders 

[moonslav59]

6 hours ago, Larry Cook said:

Mayer, sogard, Grissom Worcester 

Romero, Liendo, erhard - Portland 

arias,  alcanterra, zanetello - Greenville

Things are clogging up on the development  front for middle infielders 

Cespedes (#15) and Nunez (#41) have a chance to jump in the rankings, this year.

[sk7326]

On 5/9/2025 at 8:36 AM, Hugh2 said:

Sox had 6 in the top 100, would be 8 if the Crochet deal never happened (Teel/Montgomery).  Perales was listed as someone who "just missed" 

Probably.  Teel was easy Top 50.  Montgomery not being Top 100 would be entirely medical.  

[sk7326]

23 hours ago, Larry Cook said:

Arias is starting to get hot in Greenville. I really like his swing and eye at the plate. Still has a bit of rafeala in his swing though. 
the surprise of the year so far for me is how much better Anderson is swinging the bat. 
top of the lineup for Greenville has a lot of potential and should be fun to watch this summer. 

Glad Anderson is doing better.  

[sk7326]

Jhostnixon Garcia also off to a good start.  Chase rate is down a little - which is one of the things holding him back.  But another plus defensive CF/RF with legit power could be coming. 

[Hugh2]

33 minutes ago, sk7326 said:

Probably.  Teel was easy Top 50.  Montgomery not being Top 100 would be entirely medical.  

 

Not probably, Montgomery and Teel are both ranked in the latest top 100.

Montgomery is actually looking really really good

[Nick John]

2 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

Not probably, Montgomery and Teel are both ranked in the latest top 100.

Montgomery is actually looking really really good

Montgomery is going to be the player in that deal that hurts to have traded. But to get Crochet for him I'm alright with trading him

[sk7326]

5 hours ago, Nick John said:

Montgomery is going to be the player in that deal that hurts to have traded. But to get Crochet for him I'm alright with trading him

It's what a good farm system is for.  When the trade happened it looked like the rare trade that is good for everybody.