December prospect voting results

[Brock Beauchamp]

Thank you for voting!

Ranked Prospects

• Roman Anthony
• Kristian Campbell
• Marcelo Mayer
• Franklin Arias
• Luis Perales
• Yoeilin Cespedes
• Miguel Bleis
• Jhostynxon Garcia
• David Sandlin
• Richard Fitts
• Hunter Dobbins
• Mikey Romero
• Luis Guerrero
• Payton Tolle
• Johanfran Garcia
• Juan Valera
• Connelly Early
• Yordanny Monegro
• Conrad Cason
• Dalvinson Reyes

[mvp 78]

1. Roman Anthony
   #1 prospect in baseball
2. Kristian Campbell
   Closer to Roman than some might think.
3. Marcelo Mayer
   With Teel and Montgomery out of the picture, he's the clear #3 without much discussion.
4. Luis Perales
   I don't want to ding him for getting injured so I'm leaving him where I would have had him prior to injury.
5. Franklin Arias
   Needs to hit outside of the FCL to get any higher.
6. Miguel Bleis
   Probably at risk of falling if he has a slow start in 2025.
7. Yoeilin Cespedes
   Needs a defensive home and more PA's.
8. Richard Fitts
   Low ceiling/high floor?
9. Mikey Romero
   Added power, needs to be able to maintain the hit tool.
10. Jhostynxon Garcia
    Recently added to the 40 man. Not sure when he will get to MLB. Late 2026 at earliest?
11. Johanfran Garcia
    Good hit tool. Has work to do behind the plate.
12. David Sandlin
    Ultimately a relief profile?
13. Yordanny Monegro
    Needs to work on his fastball. May be limited once he hits AA.
14. Payton Tolle
    Could have helium once the season starts.
15. Hunter Dobbins
    May get some run in the BOS rotation in '25.
16. Juan Valera
    Long way to go. Needs to figure out a third pitch.
17. Luis Guerrero
    Pitched very well down the stretch. Will lose prospect eligibility early on in '25.
18. Connelly Early
    LHP with a lot of tools. Should be able to handle himself well through the minors and have some sort of MLB impact either in the back end of the rotation or in the pen.
19. Dalvinson Reyes
    Has 3 pitches. Throws strikes. Limited by strength and conditioning in '24.
20. Justin Gonzales
    Large frame. Lots of power. 1B/LF/DH only most likely.

[moonslav59]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Franklin Arias
4. Marcelo Mayer
5. Yoeilin Cespedes
6. Luis Perales
7. Jhostynxon Garcia
8. Mikey Romero
9. Connelly Early
10. Miguel Bleis
11. Johanfran Garcia
12. Richard Fitts
13. David Sandlin
14. Juan Valera
15. Dalvinson Reyes
16. Payton Tolle
17. Hunter Dobbins
18. Luis Guerrero
19. Yordanny Monegro
20. Conrad Cason

[smokedogg1982]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Marcelo Mayer
4. Hunter Dobbins
5. Franklin Arias
6. Yoeilin Cespedes
7. Miguel Bleis
8. Jhostynxon Garcia
9. Luis Perales
10. David Sandlin
11. Richard Fitts
12. Luis Guerrero
13. Payton Tolle
14. Zach Penrod
15. Mikey Romero
16. Allan Castro
17. Johanfran Garcia
18. Nazzan Zanetello
19. Conrad Cason
20. Jedixson Paez

[Hugh2]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Marcelo Mayer
4. Luis Perales
5. Luis Guerrero
6. Franklin Arias
7. Juan Valera
8. Miguel Bleis
9. Yoeilin Cespedes
10. David Sandlin
11. Hunter Dobbins
12. Jhostynxon Garcia
13. Payton Tolle
14. Richard Fitts
15. Conrad Cason
16. Connelly Early
17. Mikey Romero
18. Johanfran Garcia
19. Jedixson Paez
20. Justin Gonzales

[moonslav59]

Thanks for doing this. I like the final rankings.

[mvp 78]

On 1/1/2025 at 3:26 PM, moonslav59 said:

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Franklin Arias
4. Marcelo Mayer
5. Yoeilin Cespedes
6. Luis Perales
7. Jhostynxon Garcia
8. Mikey Romero
9. Connelly Early
10. Miguel Bleis
11. Johanfran Garcia
12. Richard Fitts
13. David Sandlin
14. Juan Valera
15. Dalvinson Reyes
16. Payton Tolle
17. Hunter Dobbins
18. Luis Guerrero
19. Yordanny Monegro
20. Conrad Cason

And I thought I'd be the high person on Early and Romero!

[moonslav59]

7 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

And I thought I'd be the high person on Early and Romero!

I inched them up a slot or two based on your expert opinion given in previous posts.