I can't respond to your post on the other 1B thread since bellhorn blocked me from responding on that thread because he likes to name-call but doesn't like to be responded to in kind.. So I will respond to your post here.
A fair point.
However, the title of article is wrong because Casas was having a horrible season when he was injured. His DWAR after just 28 games was -0.6, and his OPS was .580. Seriously, how hard can it be to replace those numbers?
I sincerely doubt the idea is to replace casas' .580 OPS, I would think the idea is to get much better.
But either way, campbell's .568 OPS over his last 30 games is not even replacing casas' numbers, it's even worse.