I'm not talking about fanboy posters like yourself as I obviously don't follow them.
I mainly follow top baseball writers like heyman, passan, olney, etc.
The thread subject is who is the most over rated. This has nothing to do with legal vs illegal.
Anyone who reached that club that was aided by the use of PEDs has an unfair advantage over those who didn't, thus they are over rated IMO.
Regardless whether they were illegal or not is not the point. I included McGwire on the list, he never failed a test and, heck, he retired well before 2003.
One of the most productive bats in an underperforming line up doesn't really say all that much.
Paying $20M this year for an OPS+ of 93 is not exactly a feather in hang 'em chaim's cap.
And he only gets more expensive from here on out.....