Not disputing either take, but if the AL is as blah as it looks, and the Sox still look playoff-bound in a month, then they owe it to the big league roster, coaching staff and especially the paying consumers (we who are so consumed by this endeavor) to assemble the best team possible and go for it.
If that includes Hicks, Hammy, May, Masa and your little dog, too, then Let's GOOOOOO!