Thanks for the qualifier (trying to post an icon...)
Things to consider: Verdugo turns 25 in May. Is his ceiling higher than Beni's age 22/23 seasons, when Andrew averaged 18 HR, 88 RBI, 94 Runs, 20 SB, .280 BA, .803 OPS?
Benintendi turns 27 in July... will he ever again approach his age 22/23 stats?
Regarding that -5.7 guy: what would LA have to give up to get the Sox to take TWELVE MORE YEARS of Mookie Betts?