That HR was great, and I'll bet a lot of fans forget it won the game when Varitek stuffed his mitt in ARod's face. But I'm sticking with Mueller's game-tying slapshot past Rivera's late kick-save as the most underrated, mainly because of what it represented, where and when it occurred, why it's overlooked (after Roberts steal), and who wasn't there -- like a Yankee upside-down in the bullpen, a cop refereeing a touchdown, and an announcer yelling, "Billy Muel-LER, Billy Muel-LER, Billy Muel-LER!"