Story's '23 dWAR was 1.0 with a .986 fielding %. Last year, Bogaerts' dWAR was 1.4 with a .983.
Story wasn't quite "phenomenal" -- as described by employees in the NESN booth -- nor did he make much difference in wins and losses in the tank stretch.
Bogaerts led the '22 Sox with 5.9 WAR, and wasn't "brutal, horrible, pitiful" or whatever other adjective fanalytics used to blame the season on him.
Pitching is why the Red Sox finished last. It's always the reason a Boston team sucks. But poorly-constructed pitching staffs were a staple of the Bloom Era, in all areas at one time or another: bullpen, rotation, waiver wire bargain bin dumpster diving DFAed rehabbing rejects, and zero deadline recruits of MLB mettle to stop ensuing spirals.