Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    52,066

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    45

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    (Comment removed)
  2. notin
    Can we stop pretending Boston is the only city with media scrutiny? Hader was playing in Milwaukee at the time, but we all heard about his tweets. Duran’s survival proves my point - that the treatment is different for All Stars than it is for 32yo career minor leaguers. Bauer is the former, which is why Dermody is irrelevant here. Want more proof? Read the article, which is now part of that Big Bad Boston media. Read the posts. People are defending Bauer. No one ever defended Dermody…
  3. notin
    Comparing Dermody to Bauer is a joke. The two are never going to be treated equally until Dermody wins himself a Cy Young. What Dermody did was similar to Josh Hader’s scandal. But while Dermody run out of town, Hader moved on after a simple “oops. My bad.”
  4. notin
    I’ve defended Bauer’s off-field antics more than most, but this is a weak case. First of all, is he really elite talent? Was he ever? Bauer has had one season greater than 3.1 bWAR, which is fewer than Rick Porcello. That one season was his truly elite 2018, in which he was worth 6.0 bWAR. But that was coming up on SEVEN YEARS AGO, back in a time when Corey Kluber and Porcello mattered. B-R.com lists his most similar pitchers as Chad Billingsley, Chris Young and Julio Teheran. That’s not elite company. And all of that was, again, a long time ago. Bauer is only 33, but he hasn’t faced MLB hitters in nearly 4 years. Could he pitch in MLB? I have no doubts. But will he return to being a top of the rotation arm? Most definitely not. At this point, what you get from Bauer you can probably get from any of a dozen other free agents, none of whom have his baggage…
  5. notin
    Arguing over which players are core is asking questions with no answers. Foundational/core players are players you build your team around. Since every one of us would build a team differently, we should all have different (even if only slightly) foundations/cores…
  6. notin
    The Pirates would probably give him away. He’s 25 years old, been in their system for 7 years, and lost two full seasons due to injury. After all that, his entire career that started in 2018 consists of 61 games. 37 of which were A ball or below. If the Sox want him, I imagine that’s a quick phone call
  7. notin
    How is that different than platooning other positions? Especially since platooning a DH doesn’t mean comprising the defense against, say, left-handed pitchers. The Sox platooned Refsnyder with Abreu last year. Sure Ref hits lefties much better, but the drop off in defense is beyond significant. Why is that preferable over platooning a DH where defense is not impacted at all?
  8. notin
    Abreu, Fitts and Kelly for Crochet?? How did that get to be a reasonable option? It turns out now reports are that the White Sox were really not all that interested in Abreu. Not sure what the price tag for Crochet is, but I expect the White Sox to want Campbell as a starting point…
  9. notin
    I’m fine with not including Bello as a foundational piece going forward. But the criticism of “not improving at all” is extremely premature for a player with 2 seasons that make up his entire career…
  10. notin
    Walker is only 32 and was pretty good in 2023 and 2022. Ifthe price is Yoshida, he’s worth the gamble. Sometimes a bad year is just one bad year. And I’d prefer the pitching depth over the injured DH. Of course, the Phillies already have too many DHs taking the field. Want this trade to happen? Yoshida to Philly for Walker and Castellanos. Dombrowski would jump at the chance to free up that much payroll and a lineup spot for Soto…
  11. notin
    Practice with the Celtics?
  12. notin
    According to many, Yoshida in an overpaid slap-hitting DH with no footspeed. What should the return be?
  13. notin
    Story barely played last year…
  14. notin
    Adames isn’t horrible, but he isn’t Soto either. From the names on the market, Adames is one of the better fits. Who are the other Plan B options? Bregman? Alonso? Teoscar?
  15. notin
    He was. Until someone offered it. Now he’s looking for more. Soto’s like anyone else. Once he finds what he’s looking for, he stops looking for it and moves on…
  16. notin
    Why is Campbell an option at 3b? He’s player all of 5 games there in his career, and per Soxprospects, his arm is “passable” there but better suited for 2b. Forcing a hitter into a position he’s ill-equipped to play is how bad defenses are built. I’m fine with some other internal options at 3b. But I think the Sox can do better than Campbell there…
  17. notin
    For large parts of it. But there’s one fellow who defines it “performance in the post-season and Red Sox-Yankee games.” That feels a bit personal…
  18. notin
    And I’m not wild about the term “core”. It seems to have too many negative meanings. It makes me think of apples and nuclear reactors, both of which have cores that are not good. For teams, I prefer the term “foundation.” But I won’t complain if people say core, as it is easier to type. I’ll just assume the folks who use core are horrifically lazy…
  19. notin
    Also “clutch”…
  20. notin
    Exactly. Which is why asking for proof a player is “MLB ready” is a straw man. It’s a case-by-case scenario at best, and even then the folks who do it for a living are wrong rather frequently…
  21. notin
    I doubt they want any. The whole Abreu thing looks like a falsehood…
  22. notin
    Give me a definition of MLB-Ready. Because as far as I can tell, it means something different depending on who you talk to…
  23. notin
    What’s wrong with Adames? Or do you have a fetish for sloppy play at the hot corner?
  24. notin
    Adames over Bregman. Experience be damned…
  25. notin
    Maybe Soto wants much, much less…
×
×
  • Create New...