This argument goes beyond Straw Man, right past Stick Man and directly to Brick Man on the Three Little Pigs scale.
Alcantara is an elite talent, but his backloaded contract is entering the two priciest years, a point where Miami quite often sells. Arguments that they might want him to pitch to increase his value are easily offset by arguments they don’t want to risk him pitching and being ineffective or getting hurt again.
Now I’m not sure he is actually available, but if he is, the post TJS surgery risk, while not non-existent, is certainly not high based on plenty of league wide data. And said risk is probably less than the success rate of even top prospects living up to their hype.
With his third very affordable option year, Alcantara should absolutely be worth dealing even Campbell for. I would be hesitant if they insisted on Anthony, but not necessarily immediately out…