Stop.
Eaton was not even at third base when Chisholm caught the ball cleanly. If Eaton was sent, he could easily have been thrown out at home. Hudson had no way of knowing where Chisholm was going to throw the ball. Holding Eaton was the safe move, especially with Story due up and Trevor had all the Sox RBIs and homered in his last at bat.
It just looked worse because Rice dropped the ball, but it’s not like it rolled 20 feet away. Heck if Rice caught the throw cleanly, he might have had a chance to throw Eaton out, too.
Too many are blaming Hudson for not reading the Yankees’ players’ minds and for not knowing the future…