I could see non-tendering him because it might be possible to replace him with minor league arms like like Tanner Houck or Travis Lakins for less money.
I could see tendering him because he will likely be about $2mill or so and free agent relievers will cost more.
Even if you had the numbers, it’s probably a small and irrelevant sample size against minor league southpaws over one season.
Gorkys has had significant MLB experience. And in that experience, he had limited success against MLB LHP to the tune of a .615 OPS.
Of course, this is also a limited sample size of 420 PA spread out over 8 years. But the fact that the 31yo Hernandez was kept off the field vs LHP so much in the past 8 seasons also says something...
You’re kidding, right?
Maybe because not everybody is hitting the ball equally hard? Maybe because not every player has equal line drive rates? Maybe because a juiced ball can increase the likelihood of barrel contact but can’t force the hitter to make it?
Still clinging to the one scouting ranking that has Deivi Garcia in the top 25? Everyone else has him outside of the top 60, which makes him A LOT closer to Casas than the names you seem to think he belongs with...
But how does that compare to other farms?
Bear in mind, the professional organizations saying the Sox have the worst farm aren't saying "No Major Leaguers!! Ever!!" They're saying "29 other teams have a really good chance at having more and/or better major league talent in their farm systems than Boston does."
Johnson has been up and down for 3 years now, unable to stick anywhere or stay healthy. He wouldn’t even have pitched as many MLB innings as he did if he had any options left. The only thing he has going for him is that he’s here. Head case or not, he’s really not an MLB-caliber pitcher...
Did you also like his bit about ERod's trade value being influenced by Mookie's performance?
Not to mention, for all the negative comments about the Sox farm and the positive glowing reviews about the Yankee farm, let's just stop and spot check some rosters here.
Number of Yankee drafted/developed farm products on current roster: 3 (And that's counting Brett Gardner, who graduated what, 25 years ago.) Equal to the number of Red Sox farm system products in the outfield alone...
The Sox farm system might be down now, but at least it produced something recently...
Dauby? You wanted the Sox to promote Brian Daubach?
I'm not a big fan of Gorkys, either, but even I admit he's a better choice than a 47yo former first baseman who hasn't been with the Sox since 2004....
Johnson has a 5.09 ERA as a starter this year, but a 9.90 ERA as a reliever (Ok that number does include last night's game).
Last year, Johnson had a 4.15 ERA as a starter and a 4.19 ERA as a reliever...
So if the $56mill is true in order to reset, the Sox have arbitration cases for Betts, Barnes, Bradley, Rodriguez, Benintendi, Workman, Hembree and Wright.
Who do you think should be tendered, non-tendered, and traded?
They may have to unload another deal or two.
I’d be surprised if they tendered Hembree a contract and there is the possibility of moving Barnes.
Obviously moving Price would be prudent, and don’t kid yourself, it is possible. The only question is, is what’s coming back going to make that deal worthwhile?