Do people not get how depth works? I nblame the sports media, you know, the folks who saw a team with two good quarterbacks and labeled it a “controversy”.
Just because they keep Yoshida does not impact the playing time of others if they prove better. If Campbell outhits Yoshida, he likely plays ahead of him at some point in the six month long schedule that features a game nearly every day.
Did people forget last year, this team managed to find over 250 plate appearances for Abraham Toro? That at some point, Blake Sabol was batting? Or that the 2024 Red Sox gave over 500 combined plate appearances to Enmanuel Valdez and Dominic Smith? Where were these guys on your March Depth Charts?
If your argument in March rests solely on Yoshida or Hamilton or whoever being in line for PT ahead of someone you would rather watch, that’s on you for either unrealistic expectations or favoritism. Let Campbell (who is a terrible argument for a bench spot over Yoshida) earn his way back. I think he will. I also think it’s irrelevant here.
The choice comes down to an NPB superstar or some AAAA player like Eaton or Gasper or Siegler or Sogard, I don’t get why anyone is even considering the career minor leaguers.
But hey, maybe the Sox can trade Yoshida, watch another outfielder get hurt and we finally get to see what happens if Nate Eaton gets 400 PAs against MLB pitching. I set the over/under for his OPS at .590…