First, Lugo was actually a pretty good player before he came to Boston, where his OPS was about .100 points below his career numbers. I’ve heard stories about a knuckle injury that changed the way he gripped the bat and threw the ball.
But as for Downs and his TBD potential, bear in mind he is 22, skipped AA ball, and is playing AAA after missing a season due to a pandemic. Maybe if he was in AA this year after a season off, he’d look a lot better. But he at least deserves another chance…