At the time, it was exciting to see them so close for Scherzer and Berrios, but at the end when we saw what those pitchers went for, it became obvious that he was sitting at the $1,000 table with only $500 in chips.
The real disappointment was that, as far as we know, he didn’t pursue pitchers like Jon Gray, Jose Quintana, Chris Archer, etc. And as those pitchers didn’t go anywhere, we don’t even know if he could have topped any offers. Now maybe he felt Sale and Houck were already better options - which certainly could wind up being true - but that doesn’t negate the need for pitching depth, especially in the rotation.
It’s also kind of tough to tell if he could have topped the orders for Rizzo and Gallo, since I don’t know much about the prospects the Yankees moved, and the various sources for learning anything about them give insufficient information (to me, at least). But my first thoughts are they could have topped those offers, but I’m on the fence about whether or not they should have.
And my biggest disappointment is that they simply ignored Jon Schoop, which I concluded based on an article that everyone seemed to ignore Schoop. He seemed like some pretty low-hanging fruit…