Too many have no idea what a good fielding play actually entails or even what a good fielder fielding the baseball looks like.
I loved playing baseball, and when I got too old to play anymore, softball kept me going for a while. To me, defense was always my passion (in basketball, too). As a kid, I didn't dream of hitting a game winning grand slam in the bottom of the ninth in game 7 of the World Series: I dreamed of making a spectacular catch crashing against the wall.
I was never a very good hitter, but my two favorite personal memories in sports were a defensive plays I made as a CF'er. One was robbing a guy of a HR in left-center field as i collided with the left fielder at the wall. The other was a miracle play I've never seen anyone else ever do. The ball was hit a long way over my right shoulder. I turned and ran, thinking I had no chance at catching it and would play the ball off the wall. When I turned to look, while running full speed away from home base, the ball was right there. I had not time to get my glove properly positioned so I swatted at the ball as it went by me. Somehow, the ball ended up in my glove, even though my glove was only opened facing away from the plate. I had caught the ball as my glove was moving downward away from me as the ball was past me.
My teammates and opponents were in as much shock as I was. I'll never forget that play. I probably had a few big hits here and there, despite being a below average hitter, but those memories are lost.