Cora inherited one of the worst running teams I've seen in years. We added JD, who is not known for running. Last year, we not only made a ton of base running errors, but we made a lot on defense as well. Cora greatly improved on that. He also added analytics in ways no Sox manager has ever done. True, the times are different than when Tito was manager, but Cora has done it.
Tito inherited a team that should have won in 2003.
I'm not bad mouthing Tito. He was awesome. Favoritism of vets has always been an issue with Sox managers and most MLB managers as well. Cora isn't that much different, I admit, except for maybe the HRam recommendation.
Again, Tito was a great manager with us. He had a couple blips here and there, and I get how Cora has not managed long enough to have any, but that shouldn't be held against him.
I'm not sure what was so great about 2010. True, Beckett only started 21 games, but Buch gave us 28 starts (2.33 ERA) and we still had Lester, Lackey, Wake, Dice-K and Doubront. Papelbon had an off year, which I don't blame Tito for, but Bard was great. The rest of the pen, which looks better than this year's on paper, all had ERAs over 4.40.
While we had no Manny or Jay Bay to "protect" Papi, we still had this...
Beltre .919 (28 HRs)
Youk .975 (19 HRs)
VMart .844 (20 HRs)
Pedey .860
Nava with a .351 OBP JD Drew at .793 and 22 HRs
Bill Hall even hit 18 HRs in just 344 ABs & Lowrie was at .907/
We finished in 3rd place with 89 wins.