moonslav59

My bad on Eovaldi. Kike's fWAR is better due to 110 more PAs, not really playing any better, but that is valuable, and your point is well-taken. Saying ERod's 2021 season is average based on fWAR only might be questionable. Look at bWAR: 1.8 2017 3.0 2018 6.1 2019 (3.5 average from 2017-2019) 1.6 2021 fWAR is heavily IP and K/BB influenced, which is fine but not everything. fangraphs also provides these numbers: ERA- 92 2017 86 2018 79 2019 109 2021 ERod's WHIP of 1.39 is a career high. To be fair, so is his BAbip (.365) which might show the Sox 2021 defense made this season seem below average. My point was that 2021 is not a clear career best for these 3, but cases can be made they are slightly their best years (Eovaldi's is career best- clearly).

I really try my hardest to not let 1 game or one week or month change my mind about a certain player or team strategy, but I am leaning towards these suggestion for winter moves and upgrades. I'm not going to get into the financial details, but my suggestions should not put us way over the current lux tax structure. 2022 Sox Catcher: lose Vaz's $7M option somehow. Acquire a defensive catcher known to do well with relationships with pitchers. 1B: I know the low cost Dalbec looks like a no-brainer, and Casas may make it to the bigs in 2022, but I'm thinking maybe it's time to move Devers to 1B. I'm okay with working hard with him over the winter and giving him one more year at 3B, so as of now, I'm going with Dalbec/Casas at 1B in 2022. 2B: I like Arroyo and would like to see us re-sign Iggy as the utility infielder and 2Bman. 3B: Devers for one last chance at 3B. SS: Look to trade Bogey but don't give him away. Then, sign whoever we think is the best defender at SS from Baez, Semien, Story but probably not Correa, as he may cost too much. (Not that these guys will come cheap, but saving money on Bogey will help off set this signing.) LF: Verdugo as a platoon. I'd play renfroe in LF vs LHPs and find a good defensive RF'er who hits righties well (see RF). CF: Kike FULL TIME! (This is my strongest held belief.) RF: Renfroe and a better defender who hits RHPs very well. (I do not think Duran is a good enough defender to fill this role or the back-up CF role. He might be our best trade bait.) DH: I'd look to trade JD, pay part of his salary and re-sign Schwarber. Pitching, pitching, PITCHING! Hopefully replacing JD with Schwarber and adding a SS won't break the bank, because I'd like to see major improvements to the pitching staff. Trading Bogey, JD and maybe Duran or one from Dalbec/Casas could land us cost-effective pitchers, but I have no idea who we might get for any of these players. The good thing about the change over needed for 2022 is that the players we lose or have options on were not major pluses to this year's team. ERod pitched well in the second half, and Ottavino put up some nice OPS Agaisnt numbers, but neither will be sorely missed. Their slots will need to be filled, however, as will the other staring rotation slot held by Perz/Richards/Houck. The ERod QO choice may be a closer call than many think it is, but one year deals are often overpays due to the lesser risk. For argument's sake, let's say we do not offer him a QO or he refuses it, and his slot is open. We say no to the Perez and Richards options. We'll count Ottavino and Robles, who will be FAs, as goners. The Houck-Whitlock 2022 role debate will take up much of the winter talk, here and across Sox Nation. IMO, Houck looks better suited for the pen- maybe as a very cheap closer. Whitlock looks more like a starter, and good starters are more expensive than good RP'ers, so I can see the argument for starting him, next year. Whatever choice is made will dictate a lot about who we target for upgrades to the staff. For argument's sake, I'm going to place both in the pen, just for this scenario. That leaves this as a foundation: (Note: I'm always for adding SP'er to the top 1 or 2 slots not looking for "good 5th starters," but I realize the budget doesn't always allow this.) SP1. _____________ (Maybe acquire an aging stud, so the deal is shorter) SP2. Sale SP3. Eovaldi SP4. _____________ (I'd like to see a solid #3 type here) SP5. Pivetta SP6. Seabold (___. Crawford/Winckowski/ German/ Espinal/ Bello/Groome/Murphy/Santos) RP1. Houck RP2. Whitlock RP3. ______ RP4. Barnes RP5. Taylor RP6. DHern RP7. Sawamura RP8. Brasier/Davis (Valdez/ Bazardo/Feltman/Ort/Schreiber or converted SP'er) That's basically 3-4 pitchers with one being a depth signing. I think we can get this done without breaking the bank, but maybe Henry will okay breaking the bank, this winter.

Actually, Kike and Eovaldi have had equal or better seasons, so one could argue they are not having "career years," this year. Kike: No, he's never havd over 462 PAs, before and he's going to approack 590, this year, but he had more homers in 2018 (21) and higeher OPS twice (2018 and 2015) than this year. Eovaldi: His 2013 season was clearly as good, but it was long ago. 199.2 IP 3.39 ERA His 2018 season was similar. His shortened 2020 season saw a better ERA, ERA+ and similar WHIP. Many of our prime or approaching prime players declined from 2019 or 2018. .877 Devers (.916 in 2019) .860 Bogey (.907 from 2018-2020 combined) .777 Dugo (.827 from 2019-2020 combined) .659 Vaz (.798 from 2019-2020 combined) JD is not entering prime, but he dropped off, a lot, from his 2014 to 2019 numbers. I'd also point out ERod's ERA+: 109 2017 116 2018 128 2019 n/a 2020 96 2021 (110 career) That is not "average." We have some legitimate "what ifs" to say this team could have and should have been better. I won't argue this point, however, because we were remarkably healthy and saw big upticks from Pivetta, Perez over his first 12 starts, and better thaan expected showings from Renfroe, Plawecki, Iggy, Shaw, Whitlock, Taylor, Rios and Brasier at the last minute.

I agree with everything, here, except your “from day one” thing. You changed your view when the Sox were riding high and your guys were imploding, but it’s no biggie. I appreciate an outsiders view, but I’ll never be able to wish you luck. I’m hoping you implode like you have several times, this year. With the right moves, this winter, even you will change your view about 4th place.

1. How was this season “as usual?” You never answer Ed that. 2. Yes, Perez and Richards dropped off severely, but there was always the plan that Sale would replace one, and Houck’s limited innings might be bunched as a later season starter. ERod did way better second half. Eovaldi and Pivetta remained pretty steady. Sale and Houck did not go deep into games but were an improvement over the first half starters they replaced. 3. The pen got worse- way worse. They carried the team for almost 4 months, but they broke down badly. I’m not sure it was overuse due to the lack of starter innings as the season wore on. We carried 13-14 pitchers almost all year, and shuffled minor leaguers in frequently. 4. Our defense was bad from start to finish, but it seemed like their mistakes hurt more in the second half. 5. We stopped hitting 3 run homers and more solo blasts. 6. We kept getting men on base, but we declined in big hits and increased DPs. One can easily view the first part of the season as a mirage, or a long period where everything went right, but we regressed to the norm or lost our mojo, but I still think this was a seriously flawed but good team deserving an excellent shot at making the playoffs. We improved in many areas and learned where we still need progress. We have a lot of players coming off the books and options on others. Our farm looks stronger and deeper than it has in years. While much of the farm is too far away to help in ‘22, it still is a reason to think we are moving in the right direction. Two of our best pitchers, this year, Houck and Whitlock, were in the minors before this season. When was the last time we said that? There are still 3 games left, and we’re tied. That should be viewed as a good thing, except for the fact that the last week has been a catastrophe. It seems like a month ago, we won 7 straight, but that was just last week! We thought the easier ending schedule could give an edge Maybe we didn’t deserve, and maybe the Nats will roll over for us, but now we have to hope other teams lose, too, and that sucks. I still like our chances. There are reasons why the Jays and Ms aren’t ahead of us, already. They have flaws, too- as do the Yanks. I’m still gonna watch every pitch of every game and feel confident we can win, but this past week has been brutal on all of us Sox fans. Keep the faith. Brighter days ahead!

Good advice.

Are you talking about the 70’s Red Sox? BTW, first half OPS .761/ second half .799. We ran out of the comeback mojo. 3run jobs in the first half/ solo blasts in the second. The piss poor defense caught up to us. The rag tag pen that had somehow held us together for 4 months, gave it up more often than we could handle. The Houck-Sale replacing Perez-Richards wasn’t enough. Schwarber, Iggy, Shaw & Robles gave us enough to make up the difference, but the other gave it back and more. We did get some answers to important preseason questions, and not all were what we hoped for, but I do think we filled a few holes and watched our farm improve. I’m feeling better about 2022 than I did last September or the start of this season. That is little solace, right now. To watch the promise and dream this season gave us for so long go down the drain against a team like the O’s brings us full circle to the first series of the year. We were tied with everyone before that April series, and now we’re tied for the last slot with 3 to go. How fitting. We went on a long winning streak after that sweep, but I think the magic is all used up. Maybe what I thought was grit was just a mirage- just a tease. I know it’s not over, but now we let the Ms into the party with the Jays knocking on the door. It’s hard to find optimism, right now. Probably tomorrow I’ll have a different outlook, but this is the pits.

I’m confused. I’m agreeing with you and you disagree with that.

Like clockwork. You only come out at the lowest points of the season.

Lay it on me. You were right. I was wrong. Again.

I’m too numb to be pissed.

Maybe just $3-5M is needed.

I’m rethinking my trade JD position.

With the budget savings.

Trade Bogey- love those guys that put the ball in play rather than K.

Lol

You mean sex appeal?

Top of the order. Don’t leave it to the bottom!

Waiting for a lefty pitcher in the 9th.

We have to lead the league in line outs to end innings.

WP to score- so fitting.

Their futures shares just tumbled.

When does Dalbec PH?

JD has been the one guy consistently getting on base.

I can’t believe I even sniffed at the idea that Richards might be worth the $8.5M differential on the bonus/buy out. This makes that choice a no brainer. (I know, I know, one game is too small a sample size to make definitive judgments, but I’m so done with GR.)