I read the part about Kike taking bad routes to the ball, but he has the quickest first step I have seen. (No, I can't prove it.)
It's a close call.
I was JBJ's biggest fan for many years, and I loved Lynn, too.
Maybe the fact that we have not had really great defense in CF since JBJ's early and middle career is blinding me.
It's just my opinion, and I respect anyone who thinks JBJ or Lynn were better. They both had larger sample sizes, for sure.