I'm not defending Bloom's deadline choices. I think he should have sold off all expiring assets, but I do think some of the moves set up some positions to either add depth or to possibly upgrading a few enough to let them rise, so we can spend more on upgrading other positions.
Catcher: Maybe they view McGuire like Stallings and are okay with sacrificing catcher offense to better our defense and staff-handling at this position.
McGuire, Wong or RHern (Cottam/Hickey down the line)
1B: Adding Hosmer at the minimum salary could end up being a very nice addition, assuming he can get over .700. Now, a .700 hitting 1Bman is a net negative, comparatively, but if he allows us to greatly upgrade CF, RF, SS or Pitching, then maybe it's a net plus.
Hosmer, Dalbec, Casas, Cordero (Oh NO!) (Kavadas/Jordan down the line)
LF/RF: Adding Pham may allow us to move Dugo to RF. I'm not a fan of that defensive alignment, but if we can spend more on CF (Nimmo) or sign Nimmo and Kike, then our OF looks much better with Dugo/Phan in LF, Kike in CF and Nimmo/Refsnyder in RF. (We won't carry 5 OF'ers, so maybe one gets traded.) I hate to count Duran as OF depth, but he may end up being okay in a platoon LF role ONLY.
2B/DH: Enmanuel Valdez looks like a longshot to win or play a major role at 2B or DH, but it doesn't hurt to add some depth or competition where needed.
Pitching: We didn't really add any pitching at the deadline, but we did get some looks at some young pitchers. Some have not looked too promising, but a few with bad numbers have actually shown some signs of life, such as Bello and Crawford. Winckowski looked okay for a while, but then dropped off. Maybe he needs to adjust to the adjustments teams made on him- same with Seabold.
The addition of Schreiber to the staff looks like a godsend. I hope he can continue doing well, next year, and I don't see why not. This doesn't look like a fluke. He has nasty stuff and his peripheral data looks like he's the real deal, although the sample size is kind of small.
We've also seen some encouraging play from Arroyo, although I certainly would not pencil him in at 2B with Story at SS, next season, but I feel better having him as depth or a utility player. Refsnyder has also seemingly earned a depth role, next year.
Each by themselves don't seem super encouraging, but all together, they improve our outlook and 40 man roster depth. On the flip side, one could argue these moves further solidify our mediocrity, and adding so-so players is not a step forward, but hopefully some of these guys can fill some key slots or depth slots, which will allow us to go bigger and better at as many positions as we can.
I'll be thrilled, if Henry opens his wallet enough to fill all our open slots with high or higher quality players than we've had, recently, but my gut says, there won't be enough for every need area.
CF ______ (We have to fill here)
2B/SS ______ & Story (Arroyo/EValdez)
C ______ (McGuire/Wong/RHern)
1B ______ (Hosmer/Casas/Dalbec)
RF _______ (Dugo/Refsnyder, assuming Pham in LF)
SP _______ (We need at least 1 solid SP) Pivetta, Sale/Paxton, Crawford. Bello, Mata/Wink/Seabold/Murphy/Walter
RP________ (Depends where Houck & Whitlock are slotted and how well Barnes and Schreiber finish the season. Taylor may return or a prospect helps?)