I get your point. There are steady .500 teams and rollercoaster .500 teams, and we have been the latter.
I do think getting Whitlock back was huge, but losing Duvall hurt like hell, since he was our hottest hitter. At some point, we should get Story, Mondesi and Duvall back, and we will be seeing Bello & Paxton, soon and Joely and maybe Mills, later on. Of course, we are likely to lose another player or two to injury, but I think we will be seeing a different team come July and August. (I know, we heard the same thing, last spring.)
I do realize this team could easily finish in last, again, but I'm thinking it is more likely we compete for a playoff slot, right to the end. I think our pitching staff is better and deeper than many think it is, and what we have seen, up to now, is not "the norm."
My biggest worry is the defense. If by mid season, with the return of Story and/or Mondesi, having Kike in CF and one of those 2 at SS would greatly improve the D, especially up the middle. Casas and Devers are ok to fine at the corner IF slots, so our D coulkd go from bottom 5-10 to maybe middle 10, overnight. That could boost the pitching, as well.