"punished is not the right term". I'm all ears, what terminology would be appropriate? To paraphrase, you're saying the stigma of the DH is well deserved. I'm saying if there's a stigma for the DH, a Closer should also be stigmatized. Basically, I'm hinting towards, If Rivera gets into the HOF, Papi has to as well. Both are niche roles that are part of the game as we know it. For better or worse. Just trying to clarify.