I don't have lofty expectations, but I do think our offense is better than how they performed this year. I don't think Davis destroyed the entire line up at once, but I do think that when pretty much the entire offense is underperforming their expectations, it's fair to wonder what's going on with Chili.
Perhaps it's an organizational philosophy of taking a lot of pitches that isn't working for out hitters. Perhaps many of our young guys are trying to do too much with the absence of Papi. Perhaps some of the guys are trying to pull everything or are trying to go to the opposite field with everything when they should be do the other. Perhaps it's a little mechanical flaw that a hitter has picked up because he's trying to do too much.
Whatever the case, I think a good hitting coach would be able to talk or work the batters through these things. Not that I'm calling for Chili to be replaced, but I think it's fair to question him.