Lets not get hysterical to try and shoehorn in a point. I didn't say he was worthless, I said I don't think he has much value right now. We'd be trading low while he's signed to a long term contract. He has not been able to show he can play defence at ANY position yet. He was clearly rushed through the minors without any thought to where he would play long term. Lou Merloni was on this early, asking where he could play defensively last season as he didn't see it.
And while I generally enjoy your input and posts, I think I'll side with Chris Hatfield and Ian Cundall from Sox Prospects.com on him, when they were saying as little as 10 days ago that the underlying numbers are not even supporting his improved batting average in AAA. Hopefully that will change and with luck, he will be on our team, or at least brought us something back very tasty, but he's far from a lock to be either right now.
To think he's ahead of Mayer is flat out absurd, even with Mayer's sketchy injury history.