there were some injuries and the "returning players" still had to ramp up - and in the case of Story were still bad. And also - get serious. Did you ever see a 3 week stretch where this team was truly humming? There were some good 2-week stretches ... but did this team ever really have the chance to boss a 1/3 of the season?
The team was betting on a lot of hope, same as 2022 and 2021. 2021 there was more stable talent offensively - but a TON still had to go right on the pitching side (and did!). Ultimately, Bloom and the front office took very short term, speculative decisions with pitching .. sacrificing floor for bargain-shopping ceiling. You rely on rolling the dice, the spaghetti monster can bite you.