Happy to keep telling you that our FO has sucked for years. Every squirrel occasionally finds a nut; our FO found Aceves recently and got Ortiz, Foulke, Schilling, and Cabrera, all of whom helped win a ring in 04 (though much of the work in building that team had already been done). The FO also managed to find a few nuts along the way in the draft: Bard, Pedroia, and Ellsbury are examples. Youkilis was drafted in 2001; he is not a product of the good work of our current FO (I am referring to Epstein and Cherington, not whoever was there before them). Buchholtz? Are you kidding me? He has yet to prove himself. He has pitched but a single full season in excellence, and even then he tossed only 173 innings; his lifetime ERA with Boston is over 4, as is Beckett's ERA. And to get Beckett and Lowell we had to give up Hanley Ramirez-certainly not a one sided piece of brilliance on the part of Epstein.
Do you really expect Salty, owner of a career OPS of .725 to keep a .900+ OPS? Need I remind you that after the ASB last year his OPS plummeted to .682? He will regress; he's just not that good.
Doubront? Good start. Unproven as yet.
Miller? Please. If you are using Miller to bolster your arguement you know you are in trouble.
Now lets just list a few names off the top of my head that our brilliant FO signed whose level of talent was badly misjudged:
Byun-Hung-Kim, Matt Clement, Lenny DiNardo, John Halama, Craig Hanson, Edgar Renteria, Julio Lugo, Matt Mantei, Jason Johnson, David Pauley, Rudy Seanez, Willy Mo Pena, Bartolo Colon, Michael Bowden, Paul Byrd, Daisuke Matsusaka, Brad Penny, John Smoltz, and more recently: Aaron Cook, Bobby Jenks, Justin Germano, Carlos Silva, Carl Crawford, John Lackey, Scott Schoeneweis, Ross Ohlendorf........do I really need to go on? There are lots more.
Our FO, starting about 5 years ago, lost it. They misjudged talent regularly, handed out absurd long term contracts to players of mediocre talent, and have made a desert out of our minor league system in terms of ML ready pitchers. Thats a recipe for failure; it defines incompetence.
Finally, "the proof of the pudding is in the eating". How many playoff games did we play last year? How many did we play the year before that? How many are we likely to play this year? Where are we in the standings this year, and how is our pitching doing relative to the other AL teams? How was it last year? And how was it the year before that? How big is our budget compared to that of the Rays, who are beating us in the standing pretty regularly now? I don't want to hear about injuries either. All teams get them. Its a copout and an excuse to use that. HOW HAS OUR TEAM DONE THE LAST THREE YEARS??
So sure, any time you want me to continue to tell you that our FO doesn't know what they are doing, I would be more than happy to oblige.