I like WAR a lot myself. And I know it's far from perfect.
I like the fact that the #2 and #3 WAR guys on the 2013 Red Sox were Victorino and Ellsbury, ahead of Papi. That in itself shows the weight given to fielding and speed and the measurement of the complete game of the player
I think you're right that there are a lot of exceptions, and maybe we should take a closer look at a guy like Buehrle and what made him so effective over a long career.
A slightly amusing side-note to this - remember the Sox big game plan for pitching going into the 2015 season? We were supposedly stacked with ground-ball pitchers. That was supposed to translate to great numbers, especially with all those low strikes being called!
Setting aside his monster paycheque for a moment, you can't argue with Price's attitude. He hasn't whined about anything, he hasn't blamed anyone but himself. He takes the ball every 5th day. He's a good candidate to turn things around.
I'm pretty cynical myself. I think Theo definitely has a good-sized ego and he wanted more power than Lucchino was prepared to give him. Kind of a Jimmy Johnson-Jerry Jones thing.
I think Theo's real dream job was with the Red Sox - but with total autonomy over baseball operations.
I respect the stat dig.
But if you look further, he has an .877 career OPS with a runner at first base only, so that would seem to make him a good candidate for batting second.
BTW I'll argue with you all day every day about Theo, but I do have to respect your point of view about baseball executives, because you're 100% consistent about it.
Team ERA is 4.43, 4th worst in the league.
But team runs allowed per game is 4.84, 2nd worst in the league. We seem to have given up the most unearned runs as well.
Bottom line, our run prevention is a disaster.