I don't put him in the group of elite closers, because his performance is not elite anymore, simple as that. And you clearly don't understand the definition of elite. Elite isn't a guy who guarantees a "solid" year, it's a guy who guarantees upper echelon (top 5, at worse) run prevention and baserunner prevention numbers: Kimbrel, Chapman, Davis, Miller (even if now SU man), Jansen. Longevity has little to do with it.