People don't seem to understand that extremes are bad.
If you're a Theo ballwasher you're an idiot, but if you're an illogical Theo basher, you're an idiot as well.
It's not that difficult:
He was a good GM, but he made mistakes like every other GM. The "Theo was the worst GM ever" rethoric gets tired quickly. If you want to see bad managing check out the Cubs, Baltimore, or Seattle, all teams with money that suck ass and haven't won anything in forever (see what i did there, Cubs fans?) yet the Sox win 2 WS championships in a decade, and field a contender every year. What more do people want?
A couple of good breaks in 2010, and this team makes it all the way. In 2011, the team had some construction flaws, but it's still a solid core that, with a few improvements, could go all the way.
Theo sucks? GTFO.
Theo was the best ever? GTFO.
Logic people.