Man if Youk is still carrying that one around he must have an ulcer named 3rd base eating away at his stomach lining.
I have often thought that you could really make a case that the Sox would have been better off with Youk at 1st and keeping Beltre. They would be more balanced. It would likely be a more powerful lineup, especially with Ortiz still in it.
They would not have Agons. Youk's decline has been much discussed here and if in fact this is the rapid decent of Youk then bringing in AGons instead of keeping Beltre seems like it was the right thing to do. The Ist base version of WMB is not really bangin' around down there in Pawtucket I don't think. I am not sure that what is happening to Youk as far as decline is concerned would have been much altered by his being at 1st instead of 3rd. I think he would have been happier over there but I would have a hard time finding a way to tie that to his problems at the plate. Then again, if the Sox had kept Beltre leaving them hunting for a 1st baseman as Youk declined, who would they have had to pick from then......Prince......Albert......Cuddyer....ouch!!!!
So the lineup could have been, Ells, CC, Pedey, Prince/Albert, Ortiz, Beltre, Aviles, Sweeney/Ross, Salty/Shoppach.......Holy s***! Even if you take CC out of there, a deal I hated from day one, or insert a more classical SS, that is one hell of a line up.