I think that by bringing up Iggy to play short, moving Aviles to the OF and playing MWB at 3rd (since Youk is injured anyway), you end up with much better defense, close to the same power numbers...maybe the same or better power numbers because Youk is not hitting and more speed and offensive versatility. So to me that part of what I would like to do, does not have a downside at present. You keep Aviles bat in the lineup which you want, you get d-mac out of the lineup, which you want...you put a good arm in the outfield, which you currently don't have and you end up with a monster defensive infield. I would probably not try to trade Youk...why..for what. He is on the last year of his contract and the Sox have an option on him for next year.
Now the last part would be Lavarnway. I think you have to bring Lavarnway up to play catcher. If the Sox Management came to me and said, OK buddy, we will give you the infield you want and move Aviles to the outfield but you are stuck with Salty, I would have really pushed to change that but in the end would have taken it......until today. Today all my worst fears were realized. Salty is killing this team defensively and is not hitting. He is hitting "for Salty" but that is nothing worth protecting. I don't think you can keep Salty and off Shoppach because we really don't know how long it will take for Lavarnway to truly settle in. So in my view Shoppach has to stay and Salty has to go.
Salty is dropping balls, not able to keep balls in front of him, now he is dropping pop flies. I can go on forever but why. There is not a single aspect of catching where Salty is even adequate. He is terrible in every single aspect of catching, so much so that he is now a risk factor for other team members.... literally. I meant what I said earlier during the game. At every other level of baseball than MLB they literally would have pulled the catching gear off of Salty today and put somebody else in...they would have put anybody else in. He is that bad and it is high time we stopped looking the other way and hoping something is going to change with Salty because there is no reason for it to get better.
Now I have to admit to having a bias here. I have never liked taking critical defensive positions like SS and Catcher and tossing guys that are defensive liabilities there or so called adequate defenders there just because they can hit. I am OK with doing that everywhere but Catcher and SS, the two places that the Sox stubbornly continue to do it. However call it good luck or bad, whatever. The Sox have a great opportunity here to change the profile of the team without taking to many hits from anywhere because Youk is injured and is not hitting and d-mac is not hitting. So we have a tailor made opportunity to keep Aviles in the lineup, still get Iggy in the lineup and get d-mac out of the lineup.
If by the way I could get pitching for some sort of package that included Youk and or Salty, I would do it. I would probably explore Youk but would likely not find any takers that returned me anything that would interest me. However, because Salty can at least get into a crouch without falling over (just barely) he will have trade value and packaged with somebody or somebodies, we could get somebody for Salty. Catchers are really still in short supply at all levels of pro ball. Besides, keeping Youk gives me some protection in the case that when Ells and CC come back, if Youk can hit, I may just want to go back primarily to the way this team was designed to play before all this s*** happened.
Youk becomes somebody that actually with the other players involved in the changes I would like to see gives you the chance to field two teams with completely different profiles by just changing back and forth between the opening day lineup version (without Salty but with Lavs) or this version with WMB, Iggy and with Aviles in the outfield. That might be a hell of a lotta' fun to watch. If both versions were playing well it would sure be fun to watch other teams try to figure out what to do with that two headed monster.
I will grant you that you could argue that the better pitching teams might still have us over a barrel. Maybe not though. We would have one offense that would be better at scratching out runs and one that would be better at pounding out runs with both featuring some aspects of pounding and scratching out runs.