I got your point. I understand all you say about his numbers and all that stuff.
My only remote concern is whether he already start or is about to start his decline or not, thats all. You say he is still in his prime. To me is not that clear. As I said, I need to see him next year in order to make a stronger case and emit an opinion since last 2 years for whatever reason he wasn't the #1.
On the other hand, if you ask me, Can Bautista/Cabrera/Gonzalez, etc. finish above Pujols? My answer is still yes, they can. Bautista finished with a 1.056 and Cabrera with 1.033, Pujols? .906 last year. In 2010 Hamilton finished with 1.044 and Cabrera 1.042, Pujols? 1.011.
Hell rethinking, Cabrera seems to me the most consistent than the others lately (last 2 years), regardless Cabrera is younger. Notice that I'm not saying that Cabrera or Bautista have been better career baseball players than Pujols neither two years is enough frame to make a call nor Pujols is not a safe bet. I'm just saying that this call is not an easy one as you are assuming, from my perspective.
IYO when is the right time to drop guy's career numbers in order to forecast that the guy won't be the #1 anymore? When a guy hasn't been the best, lets say, the last 3 years? 4? ? when? As I said, for whatever reason he hasn't been the best the last 2 years at OPS, and that is a fact, reason why it opens the scrutiny, and the debate.