Since day one we had a bunch of No. 4s and 5s lead by Rick f***ing Porcello and Buch. IDK you, but I did not like that by any means. Some said that this staff could be "good enough=mediocre" since the good offense blah blah. Again, I understand what they wanted/tried to to do here, but that does not mean that I liked that strategy. At the time we had a very unbalanced team, and we had a very little margin of error if the offense/run prevention/BP shitted the bed... which kind of been happening.
Also while the offense were on paper very good, there were some question marks on some players as well. There were some concerns in Sandoval, HR and XB specially at defense. Some questioned if Vic, Pedroia and others could be healthy all season long as well. Some question marks were around Papi and Napoli as well. Craig and Castillo were an mystery. etc.
As I said, on paper I did not like the strategy at all since day 1. All those questions have answers these days; unfortunately just a few are good answers.
We can split the numbers all day long, the true is that each department already taxed us in one way or another making us one of the worst teams in baseball.