.932, .920, .889, .870 are the four best OPS for Johnny Bench, Mauer has already had 1.031 and .937 in four seasons with 500 or more PA, so I think that damages your argument about Bench, just to clear that up. Also, the 2007 season was injury plagued, and like I said, he didn't find his power stroke until this season. He was an elite player, since his first batting title, that's all I'm saying. However, now that he has added power, and has built his ability to hit the ball as well, he's arguably the best player in baseball. It's a simple point, don't over-analyze it.
As for the Ichiro argument, he still lost the batting race to Mauer 3 times, it's that simple, again, don't over-analyze, it doesn't matter how many times he's hit over .350, it matters that he got beat by Mauer in three batting races in 5 years, again, it's really simple.