Yes it is too early.
Swihart, as much as I love the kid, has not been given a permanent spot yet and may never get it if many get their wish and see him traded.
I hope that he sticks in left and that Holt resumes his strongest role on this team as super-sub.
I have no doubt that SWihart can hit enough for left. I continue to worry about Bradley. Betts will be one of the best outfielders in the AL someday.