No no no, in the 2016 Talksox world, it only matters if you have 100% confirmation for an opposing viewpoint. Inferences and reasonable assertions no longer matter. If you're a Buchholz apologist, no amount of s***** pitching will change your worldview because good Buchholz is right around the corner. It was totally reasonable to re-sign Buchholz because there was a great chance that he'd be a #2 in this rotation. No matter how bad he sucks, he is still a valuable commodity because he may one day pitch well over a few starts and if he keeps sucking you can surely flip him to another team as part of a package to bring in a better pitcher.