Listen if it's my personal choice the re-sign him. But if it's going to take a CC type contract to do it, I can see why some would be hesitant.
So let's play the "Comparable contract" game,
Player A(NL&AL)
(2001-2009)
106-68 3.79 ERA 228 games 1401.1 IP 1280 hits 641/590 R/ER 426 BB 1330 K 1.22 WHIP
Player B(NL&AL)
1999-2009)
100-85 3.84 ERA 244 Games 1583.1 IP 1392 Hits 744/676 R/ER 665 BB 1473 K 1.30 WHIP
Player C(NL)
2001-2009
105-68 3.51 ERA 259 games 1551.1 IP 1313 Hits 669/605 R/ER 698 BB 1324 K 1.30 WHIP
I would say those players are comparable. This would lead me to believe Becketts next contract will probably fall between 15-18M. Which I could get on board for.
Here's what I would offer,
2010- 11M,2011- 13M, 2012- 15.5M, 2013- 16.5M, 2014- 18.5M, Vesting option for 19.5M for 2015.
So it comes out to a 1M more on top of his original raise for 2010. Then 4 yrs 74.5M in extension money, with an obtainable option(or just guarantee it) of 19.5M, making the whole deal 5 years 94M, which is a fair deal IMO.