Who is this guy? What a loser.
Ok, a somewhat sensible post. The point is, what is more likely to happen. All things breaking right, or the Tigers rotation maintaining the status quo?
For example..what's more likely? Varitek to rebound, or play like he did last year? You are hoping Matsuzaka, who is an unknown, pans out. You are hoping that Beckett rebounds and pitches well, that Schilling doesn't decline, Papelbon makes a smooth transition...etc. A lot of things have to go right for the Sox to have the best rotation in baseball. As it stands now, all Detroit has to do is repeat what they did last year. What's so difficult to understand about this? I'm not debating who has a better rotation, the Yankees or the Sox...I am saying about all of baseball. In order for the Yankees to have the best rotation in baseball, Wang has to continue to dominate, Mussina has to maintain his productivity and not decline, Pettite has to pitch like he did in the second half of the year in Houston, Igawa turns out to be a solid but unspectacular pitcher, and Pavano has to stay healthy and pitch to his potential.
That's a LOT of ifs. Hence, they don't have the best rotation. They have more if's than the Sox. Hence, the Sox have a better rotation. Simple enough for you?