so since he is having a good half month against some of the worst pitching money can buy he cannot be considered a bust?
Overall, fire_theo's claim is ridiculous in wanting Trot over Drew based solely on performance. Nixon can barely move without tearing a ligament or breaking a bone. The guy played hard and is paying the price for it. He is not a regular starter in the bigs, hell if it wasnt for his distant past, he wouldnt be a major leaguer at all. Nixon is done.
At the same time, Drew has been awful. He's being paid to be a middle of the order force and he is producing worse than a gimpy Johnny Damon. If he wanted to use the argument that the contract is ridiculous, he would have a great point. If he wanted to use the point that Drew's contract and position demands will put a strain on development/performance, you have another point. But to say that right now Trot Nixon is better than JD Drew is stupid, pure and simple.
As a yankee fan, I get to sit back and watch this bear of a contract unfold for 4 more seasons and say, hey I called it. Signing a 32 yr old player with a history of being unable to play through pain to a 5 yr 70 mil contract while KNOWING he had a MAJOR defect in his shoulder is bad business and should be a black mark on Theo's otherwise pristine record. Drew is not fast enough or good enough a fielder to play CF, so he is clogging up a position that requires middle of the order production. And assuming that he regresses as he ages like most players, he may not get much better. Going around the league, there are few teams with a worse RFer. He's the worst RF in the AL East and aside from Texas who has no set RFer, no other team has a worse set RFer. He will be a bear, and with his contract being so fresh and his production being so poor, he is not tradeable or waivable and the sox will not want to eat such a large amount of money for nothing. So this guy plays for at least the next 2-3 yrs until the amount of sunk cost drops precipitously enough to cut him. Either way, looks good from our end.