I said B. I know I'm usually not too hard on the team or management but given the constraints BC had, I think he did alright. For the people saying the team is no better than at the end of last season, I don't think there was much hope of re-signing Papelbon. Whatever his reason for leaving, be it to get the taste out of his mouth of blowing that save to the Orioles to getting more money, it would have been hard to keep him. Ortiz had such a good season, I would have wanted him around again anyway. And I don't like the Scutaro trade, but I'm holding off criticism until Aviles or Punto show what they bring to the table.
As a financial analyst, I understand what Cherington was going for. By signing all these "pitching reclamation projects", he's diversifying the risk in hopes of finding some sturdy starter in the backend of the rotation. I can't really blame him, considering in recent years how disappointing it can be to throw all your money at one player. I don't feel as confident as I did going into last season, but who could have foreseen Carl Crawford and John Lackey struggling as they did?